Review: Dude Thing Creations Guitar Stand

Dude Thing Guitar Controller Stand

The past couple months have shown a marked increase in music games like (and including versions of) Guitar Hero and Rock Band. And while these games are very fun, where do you store all your guitar controllers, since few allow for interoperability? Dude Thing Creations has offered up a solution: a guitar stand!

When our model arrived, I was a bit confused, because the box said, "Fragile Glass" on it. As I gingerly removed the parts from the packing newspaper, I found no glass, but rather that they'd just used an available box. So if packaging is important to you, you'll be disappointed. The crumpled newspaper did protect the pieces from scratches and damage, but it took me a few minutes to find the envelope containing the instructions.

You'll need a philips screwdriver and a scissors to put this together, since the plastic angle brackets still have tabs on them that need to be removed, and breaking them off leaves jagged edges. (I used a wire cutter for a nice clean cut.) The guide holes seemed a bit too small, so I had a difficult time getting the screws in, especially since it had some odd angles to work with, but 75 minutes later, it was assembled. That they only used 1 size of screw made it slightly easier, and if you have an electric screwdriver, you'll be able to use it on some of the screws. By the way, step 7 is missing from the instructions. It should read, "Screw hook screws into remaining guide holes by hand."

But how is the quality? Made from a painted pine post and birch bases, I wouldn't mind something just a bit sturdier. It'll hold up to some guitars and a few bumps, but if your jam session gets too wild, resulting in someone falling on this thing, it'll probably break. I recommend storing it in a corner somewhere. The paint job is good enough, but something more of a laminate would give it a smoother finish.

The design holds up to 4 guitar controllers and 1 microphone. Guitar Hero guitars hang from the rack, but the longer Rock Band guitars have to lean. An adjustable or higher rack would solve this problem. The hooks help hold the stray cords for the mic and older guitars. The top shelf offers a place to either set extra standard controllers, or, for those looking for subtlety, a long tablecloth with a plant or other knick-knack. A tablecloth will also cover the "Dude Thing" sticker on the top if you're not into branding. Additional microphone slots can be included in the order for $3 each for the SingStar fans, and for an extra $10, you can add cup holders to the top, although it's too high to reach over comfortably from your recliner.

While the Dude Thing Guitar Stand does the job as advertised and will help contain your guitar controllers. With Guitar Hero World Tour and Rock Band 2 on the horizon, you may need something like this. Is it the most elegant possible solution? Probably not, but since my wife won't let me buy a wall-mounted sword rack for my guitar controllers, this seems to be the next best thing.

Thanks for the writeup

Dale,

Thanks for the writeup and for the honest evaluation. I'm confused about why you felt the need to cut anything off of the corner braces. There's a tab on the corner brace that's designed to close like a door and conceal the screws inside. It also provides additional shear strength to the entire piece so it definitely should NOT be cut off. This might be contributing to the perceived lack of sturdiness.

We considered elevating the rack so that all guitars would hang, but there's a certain guitar for Guitar Hero that has a fairly weak neck (I don't remember the name at the moment), so we didn't want to make owners of that guitar hang their guitars from their already weak necks. We had to leave it high enough though so that the Les Paul (the white one in the picture) would hang since it's pointed end makes leaning problematic.

Your observation about the holes is fair, but I want to point out that all of the parts for this piece are hand made, so it's pretty much impossible for us to get them dead on every time. The holes are not strictly necessary to be able to assemble the product, but we put them there to act as visual guides. Even if you don't hit the hole exactly, it's not going to affect the pullout strength of the screw. Incidentally, this means you can ignore our screw holes on the center post and vary the height of the rack to whatever height you want, but our pre-drilled holes should properly accomodate 99.9% of people's tastes.

Thanks again for the honest evaluation!

Thanks, Kevin

That explains a lot. I didn't see anything about the tabs for the corner braces in the instructions, so I assumed the tabs were just factory leftovers.
For clarification, it's plenty sturdy, but pine is a soft wood. It's definitely better than the cheap particle board stuff you get at Wal-mart and will likely last for years, but a harder wood would last even longer.
And good to know that those weren't intended to be guide holes. Improve the instructions a bit, and you'll take care of my biggest concerns.
--
Dale
Tech Talk for Families Cohost

Disappointed.

I just received this stand and I’m terribly disappointed. I ordered it because I thought they could do a more professional/polished job than I could at home. Boy, was I wrong! Most of the pilot holes were in the wrong places, none of the edges are sanded, there are scratches in the wood that have been finished over. The finish itself is drippy. The bottom piece is warped and the whole thing wobbles like it’s drunk. I am in the process of requesting a partial refund because I don’t want to lose $30 in shipping costs both ways by returning it.

Alternative Stands and Hangers

Kudos to Kevin on such a cool design!!! If you would like to see an alternative, check out the original Rock Hero Guitar Stands and Hangers at www.measuretwiceproducts.com.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote> <p> <br> <b> <i> <s> <img src> <u> <table> <tr> <td> <hr>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may link to Gallery2 items on this site using a special syntax.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Youtube and google video links are automatically converted into embedded videos.
  • E-Mail addresses are hidden with reCAPTCHA Mailhide.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Syndicate content Syndicate content